I was literally giggling with glee at the result of this week's Survivor tribal council, as Joel reaped what he had sown. The beauty of it is that even though he recognized the poetic justice of the situation a priori, once the axe came down on his head his final remarks indicated he could dish it out but couldn't take it. "How could they vote to keep someone like Chet?" he asked. He should know the answer to that, because he did it twice himself!. Joel went about the game all wrong from the start. The Fans should have banded together from the outset under the theory that the advantage would be with the Favorites' greater experience, and so they needed to remain united to have any chance. Instead Joel began by picking off the greatest threats to him personally, ignoring the larger needs of his team. Good riddance to bad rubbish, says I.
But let's talk about Cirie, who looked like she'd swallowed the canary during tribal council. That woman is playing the game harder than anyone else on the island, and none of the other players even know it. If they realized how crafty she's being, they'd bounce her in a heartbeat. She's doing all the right things. To stay alive, she has to band together with other "weaker" players and pick off the strong ones until the merge. While it's a team game, the physically weak are vulnerable, but once it becomes an individual game the equation inverts and the physical threats need to watch their backs while the weak cruise forward. Her game is all about surviving to the merge. I'm a little surpised Ozzy and Amanda agreed to oust Joel-- I'd have thought they'd have been confident enough to keep him around for the sake of a stronger tribe. All they have to do is make it to the merge and get reunited with James and Parvati, and the four of them are in a potentially great position.
I can't wait to see the faces of the other tribe when they learn that Joel was voted out. I'm predicting slack-jawed shock all around.
That was a brutal reward challenge. I suspect the producers had no idea it would become such an injury factory. But really-- Joel and Chet? How either of them agreed to that pairing is a mystery. I hope Jonathan isn't removed from the game because of his injury. That's just a horrible way to leave Survivor, not knowing if you'd have been able to make it to the end. But that wound looked nasty, and a choice between staying in the game and risking death is no choice at all.
Posted by Peter at March 9, 2008 02:17 PMYeah. It's as if the Devil has a seemingly endless supply of pacts.
All hail Mark Burnett.
Posted by: Dave Arnott on March 10, 2008 01:49 AMHmm. I could comment on this "endless supply of pacts", but doing so would require that I comment on the last two episodes. Since I'm not sure Peter has seen the last two episodes (and I have a documented history of sabotaging him in this regard) I must remain silent.
Posted by: Stephen Glenn on March 22, 2008 08:42 AMI'm fully caught up on all my reality shows except Top Chef, so comment away.
Posted by: Peter on March 23, 2008 09:01 PMPerhaps you can guess what I'm going to say. In the last two episodes we've lost four contestants. That's two episodes fewer than the producers expected to run. I would think that not only screws up their schedule, but it also takes a nasty cut into advertising revenue.
On the other hand, I don't know how it works in TV Land. Maybe Burnett is insured against such mishaps.
Posted by: Stephen Glenn on March 25, 2008 09:13 PMI don't think it cut into the episode count at all. There were 20 contestants when they started. In season one there were 16. So they had more players than they needed to run the game. In past seasons, they've had episodes with double eliminations-- the dreaded note that will be read at tribal council, announcing they have to immediately vote another player out, or the always dissatisfying "both tribes must vote someone out tonight" non-challenge.
The unexpected exits of Jonathan and Kathy just made those kludges unnecessary, accomplishing the same thing with far more drama.
The devil wins again.
Posted by: Peter on March 26, 2008 08:13 PM